A recent quip by Jerry Manuel from Adam Rubin’s blog prompted this post:
At one point postgame, Manuel praised the organization’s front office for having such depth that R.A. Dickey and Hisanori Takahashi were available to step into the rotation.
“I think the organization did a good job in creating depth,” Manuel said. “I’ve said that a number of times.”
“Or,” Manuel continued, referring to spring training, “maybe we took the wrong people. You never know. We could have did that, too.”
Just to refresh everyone’s memory, at the end of March, Jerry Manuel and Omar Minaya felt that:
– Chris Carter did not belong on the 25-man roster
– Gary Matthews, Jr. did
– GMJ should be starting ahead of Angel Pagan, or at least platooning with him
– Ryota Igarashi was the top choice for setup man / 8th inning role
– Sean Green was a key component of the bullpen
– John Maine and Oliver Perez were legitimate, mid-rotation MLB starters
– R.A. Dickey was AAA fodder
– Hisanori Takahashi was a mopup man
– Jennry Mejia was more valuable as an MLB reliever now than future starter
– Dan Murphy was the best option for first base
– Mike Jacobs was the next-best option for first base
– The aforementioned Chris Carter was not part of that conversation
– Ike Davis needed more seasoning
And if you go back a few months, to before the start of spring training:
– Kelvim Escobar was a good risk to invest in, and the top candidate for the setup role
– Omir Santos and Josh Thole would be fine as the 2010 catching tandem
– Rod Barajas was a last-minute, desperation, third choice after Bengie Molina and Yorvit Torrealba
– Jason Bay would step in and provide the homerun power the team so desperately needed
– An average-performing, innings-eating starter was not necessary
What a difference a few months makes, eh?