Series Preview: Atlanta Braves vs. New York Mets

The New York Mets enter its three-game series with the Atlanta Braves as the hottest team in baseball, having won eight consecutive games. The Mets swept their last two series against the Marlins and Phillies and have not lost a game since the Braves defeated them twice on April 10th and 11th. The Braves are the only team to defeat the Mets in a series this season.

Pitching Matchups:

RHP Trevor Cahill (0-1, 15.43 ERA) vs. LHP Jon Niese (1-0, 1.59 ERA)

LHP Eric Stults (0-1, 6.30 ERA) vs. RHP Dillon Gee (0-1, 7.59 ERA)

RHP Julio Teheran (2-0, 3.71 ERA) vs. RHP Bartolo Colon (3-0, 2.25 ERA)

It’s still early in the season so some of the numbers are going to be inflated, like Cahill’s 15.43 ERA or Colon’s surprising 3-0 record. All early season stats aside, the Mets have pitched very well as a team through 13 games. The 3.00 ERA posted by the staff is good for 7th in the major leagues and just behind the Nationals (2.97) for best in the division.

Both teams have their back-end starters pitching the first followed by the two Opening Day starters to finish up the series. Niese has only allowed two earned runs all season in his two starts and earned a no-decision against the Braves, when he pitched five innings and allowed only one earned run (three total). I give Niese the advantage over a shaky Cahill, who was hit hard (four runs in two innings) in his only start this season.

The Gee-Stults matchup is probably the worst matchup of the series, but it has potential to be very competitive. Gee had a rough outing against Atlanta in his first start of the season, going five innings and allowing five runs, while Stults allowed three over five innings in a win for the Braves. I anticipate this game will be won by the pitcher who can do the best job of damage control.

Colon continues to baffle me with how well he has pitched this year. In his first three starts, Colon has posted gamescores of 69, 58 and 66 to earn a victory. Oh, did I mention he also has two RBI at the plate? That’s two more than Curtis Granderson has this year.

Teheran held the Mets to only two hits and one earned run in his start on the 11th of this month. He pitched himself out of the trouble he caused with four walks. Although he only gave up two hits, Teheran was far from dominant. I expect to see good outings from Teheran and Colon in this game, leaving it up to the bullpens to decide a winner.


The Mets bullpen is without two keys members. Obviously, Jenrry Mejia is not pitching, but the recent loss of left-handed-specialist Jerry Blevins hurts as well. Blevins made seven appearances and didn’t allow a hit before he was injured. Jeurys Familia has converted on all six of his save chances serving as Mejia’s replacement. Sean Gilmartin (6.00 ERA) is a lefty who will see more innings with Blevins out, his only blemish being a home run allowed to the Phillies.

The Braves are also using a replacement closer, but for a different reason. The Craig Kimbrel trade to San Diego caught everyone by surprise, but it’s nothing that NL East opponents will be complaining about. RHP Jason Grilli, 38, has been a lockdown closer so far this season with six saves already, while only allowing one run. This is not the same big-name Braves bullpen that Fredi Gonzalez had when he was hired, but it is still a talented unit.

One-time All-Star closer Jim Johnson is back ion MLB after his complete implosion (7.09 ERA) with the A’s and Tigers last season. Johnson has a 4.91 ERA in his seven appearances this year. Left-hander Andrew McKirahan will not be pitching any time soon after he was slapped with an 80-game suspension for taking a banned substance.


Both of the teams have one elite defender on its roster, for the Mets it is Juan Lagares and for the Braves it’s shortstop Andrelton Simmons. A two-time Gold glove winner, Simmons has posted the best defensive WAR in the National League in each of the last two seasons. While Lagares only has one Gold Glove to his name, he is still the best defensive center fielder in the game. The only player to have a better defensive WAR than Lagares last year was, you guessed it, Simmons.


With both David Wright and now Travis D’Arnuad on the disabled list the Mets offense has been led by newcomer Michael Cuddyer and Lucas Duda. Cuddyer has hit safely in nine of the last ten games and is second on the team with a .333 avg. The only player hitting the ball better than Cuddyer right now is Duda, who is hitting .347 in his first 47 at-bats. Duda has yet to show that 30-home-run power that he proved he had last year.

New acquisition Nick Markakis has shown that he was valuable signing, leading the team with a .375 batting avg. in the 11 games he has played. The Braves are lacking in home run power this year with no Jason Heyward nor Justin Upton in the lineup. Freddie Freeman is still in town and leads the team with four; after him, A.J. Pierzynski has three in only five games.

I don’t think the Braves have enough offensive firepower to defeat the Mets with how hot they are right now. No Wright or D’Arnaud isn’t desirable but Eric Campbell has done a serviceable job replacing the captain and Anthony Recker or prospect Kevin Plawecki will be able to fill in for a few weeks.

Max Gross is a Sports Media and Strategic Communications student at Oklahoma State University. Max is lifelong baseball fan and has been writing for three years and is excited to contribute to Mets Today. His favorite Mets memory is experiencing an improbable no-hit bid by Bartolo Colon in person. Max also writes about college baseball for CowboysRideForFree and can be followed on twitter @maxgross55.
  1. Bat April 21, 2015 at 10:34 pm
    Tonight is another example of Collins’ bullpen management that I don’t understand.

    Niese gives up a solo home run to Maybin to break up the shutout and make the game 7-1, so Niese is pulled from the game.

    I have absolutely no issues with this move because Niese was laboring and seemed done.

    So Collins goes to Goeddel! Great! It is 7-1, and a perfect time to see what the rookie has.

    Now here’s what I don’t understand: Goeddel walks the first batter on four pitches.

    Freeman is up next, and instead of seeing how Goeddel can fare against the second hitter he will face, he yanks Goeddel and brings in Alex Torres.

    Is that necessary?

    If Goeddel can’t pitch to more than one hitter in a 7-1 game, when can he pitch?

    Even if Goeddel gives up a home run to Freeman, the game is still 7-3 in the 7th inning.

    Is it really necessary to go to a a lefty to face Freeman in a 7-1 game?

    Doesn’t make sense.

    Would Goeddel have gotten the chance to face more than one hitter if the game was 10-1? Or 12-1?

  2. Bat April 21, 2015 at 10:41 pm
    Sorry, I watched the game on DVR and got confused. The game was 5-1 when the Goeddel nonsense went on, not 7-1.

    But the point is still valid – give Goeddel a chance and if he gives up a jack then it is only 5-3.

    • Extragooey April 22, 2015 at 10:57 am
      Are you serious? You don’t give Freeman a shot against Goeddel to make it potentially 5-3. It’s already in the 7th and you want to risk letting the Braves get close in enough so they can tie it with a bloop and a blast. It was definitely the right call then. No, the point isn’t valid at 5-1 in the 7th.
  3. argonbunnies April 22, 2015 at 3:59 am
    In general, I am fine with a manager saying to a reliever, “You walked the first guy you faced, which is an unpardonable sin, so you’re outta here.” Especially when none of the pitches were near the catcher’s target, which was the case with Goeddel.

    The only issue in this case is that Goeddel’s rust was Terry’s fault in the first place, for not using him in 10 days. Pulling him was the right move to win tonight’s game, but it was a bad move for the games to come. As was not using Robles. As was using Alex as a LOOGY and Gilmartin as a full-inning guy, which is backwards (check out Gilmartin’s righty splits in AAA — not pretty).

    In Terry’s defense, we have seen him give important relief innings to young kids before, so presumably he’ll come around eventually. I just hope Carlos Torres’s arm doesn’t fall off before then.

    • Bat April 22, 2015 at 11:00 am
      Argon, I hear what you’re saying about “You walked the first guy you faced (and none of the pitches were close) so you’re out of here” but if a guy like Goeddel can’t face a left-handed hitter in April, then why have him on the team?

      I mean, I know every game matters but this isn’t serious crunch time like August or September – it’s the beginning of the third week of the season and he can’t face a second batter (who is a left handed hitter)?

      You bring up a very good point in saying that Collins made a mistake in not using him for 10 days – that is indeed the first mistake. But I would argue that pulling a guy after one batter and four pitches in an April game is a mistake.

      Now is the time to give guys a chance to get people out, so then when the season starts to grow long in the tooth you know who you can rely on and who you can’t. But now is the time to give guys a chance and I’m not sure a single batter of four pitches is a real chance.

  4. argonbunnies April 22, 2015 at 4:07 am
    Positive notes:

    Plawecki showed a quick bat and called a good game. He also sets up in the strike zone, unlike d’Arnaud, who often sets up off one corner or the other. I dunno how the pitchers feel about this, but it looks more confident to me.

    Niese had good stuff. Good break on his curve, good bite on his cutter, respectable velocity on his fastball. There’s something weird going on with his delivery, where he flies off the mound toward third base after release every once in a while. He also looked like he was hurrying somewhat. He kept it off the fat of the bats for 6 innings, then got the hook at the right time.

    Campbell’s no gold glover, but he looks like a major league third baseman.

    After missing high on a few pitches as he often does, Alex Torres dropped two nasty strikes on Freeman for the K.

    Joe, if you’re reading, you might want to listen to Gee’s interview in the top of the third. He talks about watching video of his mechanics and working with Warthen to correct over-rotation.

    • Joe Janish April 22, 2015 at 6:11 pm
      Thanks Argon, I did see Gee’s interview. For me it was yet another example of how backward the dinosaurs of MLB are in regard to science. First off, Warthen isn’t expert in kinesiology and shouldn’t be making ANY kinds of mechanical adjustments. The two of them watching video is like the blind leading the blind (no offense to the blind readers out there). But that’s a baseball-wide issue. Second — and this is a HUGE problem in baseball at all levels — it was an example of a made-up baseball term that is wildly misunderstood because it has no scientific basis. “Over-rotation” can mean 100 things to 100 different people. I actually felt bad for Ron Darling when he was asked by Gary to explain what Gee meant by the term. Darling did a nice job of skirting the question, and that was the best he could do, because even he couldn’t be completely sure of what Gee/Warthen were discussing or tweaking. It’s as useless as when you hear terms like “dead arm” or “good drive” or “load” or “going downhill” or “staying closed” — the image in the person’s head speaking the term may or may not match the receiver’s image, because there is no standard definition.

      BTW Darling’s descriptions of “throwing from the ear” and “short-arming” (egad, two more!) were scary too. In MY mind, it sounds like something that Johan Santana did (and Bartolo Colon does) that shredded his shoulder and also could cause injury to the elbow.

      • mckeeganson April 23, 2015 at 7:51 pm
        Not trying to sound rude here Joe, but many of us readers used to come here for your analysis on everything to do with the games, not just the pitching mechanics/kinesiology. I mean we get it, you’re fired up about this and feel a strong need to call out baseball for their ignorance on this matter. If there was a balance where you touched on that as well as all other matters pertaining to the games I wouldn’t have any problem with it at all. Thing is, the Mets are currently riding an 11 game win streak and whether that is due to a lot of smoke and mirrors or not is a HUGE story and should be at least the main topic of debate. I often don’t agree with your pessimistic view of the team, yet I fully respect it and consider it a good counter balance to my own over eager opinion of the Mets ball club. I can’t help but feel like you have been waiting for that 5 game losing streak to chime in ‘I told you so” but I think you’re better than that.

        So all that said, would love to see a piece that lays out your thought’s on their start or at least a few notes in the comments.