Steve Popper recently wrote that The Mets Could Use Omar Minaya’s Help in Digging Up Good Deals, pointing out Minaya’s apparent skill in finding undervalued talent:
While Oliver Perez and Luis Castillo are the contracts that are defining Minaya right now, think instead of R.A. Dickey, Endy Chavez, Jose Valentin, Marlon Anderson, Chris Woodward, Damion Easley, Darren Oliver and Chad Bradford. Think of Fernando Tatis – at least early in his tenure with the team. Angel Pagan and Pedro Feliciano were bargain pickups. Even in trades Minaya managed to find undervalued gems as often as he missed.
First of all, Angel Pagan was originally a Met but sold to the Cubs, then required two minor leaguers to get him back — so I’m not 100% on board with his being evidence of genius. Similarly, the Mets sold Pedro Feliciano to Japan for a year before bringing him back. I might also argue that the Dickey pickup was sheer luck, but I’ll grudgingly give Minaya the benefit of the doubt on that one. But the other players are good examples that support the argument.
It’s a common feeling among those who watch and cover the Mets that Minaya has a special eye for talent, and is particularly astute at finding “diamonds in the rough”, and/or gems from the junk pile. For a long time, I shared that belief, but decided to look further into this theory.
As for Minaya’s ability to find great value in trades — well, that’s absolute poppycock. Go to MetsmerizedOnline to see Omar Minaya’s trade history (through December 2009; it doesn’t include his 2010 blockbusters) and see for yourself.
But I didn’t think he was much of a trader anyway; for every Johan Santana steal there is a J.J. Putz debacle. So, I focused this myth on the free-agent pickups. My investigation consisted of sifting through all the free-agent signings, waiver wire pickups, and Rule 5 picks listed on the transactions page of Mets.com during Omar Minaya’s tenure. I may have missed some names, since it appears that Mets.com doesn’t list every single minor league pickup. Additionally, some trades that were for a player to be named later may have been misreported as free agent signings (i.e., Trot Nixon); but they still fit into the same myth. After looking at all the players signed through the years, and the number of “finds”, I have to say this myth is busted; Omar Minaya’s success in turning other men’s junk into some kind of treasure was more a function of “throwing as much paint on the wall as possible to see if anything sticks” — there were close to 200 free agent signings, waiver claims, and Rule 5 picks as listed below (191 to be exact).
Review the list of below and report your own opinion in the comments. Continue reading →