Buzz Baloney

I’m not crazy … there wasn’t this much “buzz” last winter, nor any other winter before. On the one hand it’s fun, on the other it can be annoying. I’ll stand by my theory that the “buzz machine” of traditional media has been turned on full blast due to the great success of fan blogs — particularly the outstanding job done by Matt Cerrone at MetsBlog. The newspapers and magazines have FINALLY caught on to the fact that the majority of people who read sports check their favorite blog first, so the best way to grab eyeballs is to get a linkback to their story on MetsBlog.

Matt, we applaud you sincerely for becoming the most important internet media outlet regarding the Mets. You have done and continue to do a fine job.

The side effect is that the “professional” writers are spinning up nutty stories as fast as they can dream them up — the more outrageous, the better, since those will have the better chance of getting picked up. Oh, and they want to be the “first” with the story as well — rarely does the second source make it to the blog posts. Which is a problem, since it seems the majority are actually manufactured opinions or rumors not checked for validity. Can’t blame them, though, since they’re losing their readership. Bottom line is the eyeballs, not the facts. But the term “buzz” now encompasses rumors, conjecture, and truth — how are we to tell what’s what?

I should have started this a few weeks ago, but better late than never. Beginning now, we’ll keep a selective log of the “buzz” here: Buzz Baloney. Once spring training starts in February 2008, we’ll go back and see which of the pundits were most reliable.

Part of the fun of baseball is keeping score, right?

If you see something that you think should be added to the Buzz Baloney list, drop me a line through the contact page. Thanks.

Posted in Hot Stove | Comments Off on Buzz Baloney

Yorvit? Say It Ain’t So

According to Newsday‘s David Lennon and Ken Davidoff, the Mets are about to sign Yorvit Torrealba.

Per the article:

“Having lost out on Jorge Posada, the Mets are wasting no time in trying to close a deal with Yorvit Torrealba, and it looks like an agreement could be struck by the end of this week.

General manager Omar Minaya, spurned by Posada’s decision to return to the Yankees late Monday, contacted Torrealba’s agent yesterday with the intent of moving ahead quickly, according to a National League official familiar with the situation.”

Let’s hope that this is pure, highly adulterated bunk.

And there is a good chance that it is, in fact, bunk. Check out the last few words in the above-quoted text, specifically:

“. . . according to a National League official familiar with the situation.”

Who might that be? Someone who does the contract filing in the NL offices? Possibly. If so, he / she would be a pretty reliable source, we’d think. Let’s hope that it instead is the cleaning lady for the secretary of someone who does the contract filing, and she got the names or teams mixed up.

As Matt Cerrone has stated several times over the past few days on MetsBlog, the fascination with Torrealba makes no sense. Let’s take a look at who Yorvit Torrealba is:

1. A very average defensive catcher.

2. A below-average offensive catcher.

3. A below-average offensive catcher playing half his games in a hitter’s park.

4. A catcher who never caught more than 76 games in a season before 2007.

5. A catcher whose career high in games caught is 113.

6. A player who has never had 400 at-bats in one season.

7. A batter with these career numbers: .251 Avg., .313 OBP, .391 SLG.

8. A batter who strikes out once out of every five times he comes to the plate.

9. A batter who grounded into 19 double plays last year — in less than 400 ABs.

10. A player who at age 29 is not expected to improve.

On top of all the facts above, there’s speculation that the Mets are offering Torrealba a three-year, $15M deal. WHAAAAA ? $15M for a mediocre to below-average catcher? Makes me think about strapping on my old shin guards and walking into Omar Minaya’s office to plead for a five-minute tryout. If I’m Ramon Castro, I may hold the pen for a few more days and then demand a similar deal. I don’t see a significant difference between Castro and Torrealba, other than the fact that Castro projects to be a better offensive player. Take a look at each player’s career numbers on Baseball Reference and you be the judge:

(go ahead, I’ll wait)


Ramon Castro
| Yorvit Torrealba

Back already? Good. Did you see what I see? Did you see two journeyman catchers, with nearly identical career offensive numbers? OK, Castro looks like more of a slugger, I’ll give you that.

The “buzz” is that Torrealba is highly regarded as a defensive backstop. Huh. That’s a funny one, especially since Yorvit was second to last in the NL in throwing out baserunners — he threw out 15 and allowed 61 SBs, for a 19.7%. As a catcher myself, I do understand that stolen bases are allowed more often by the pitcher than the catcher. But less than 20% is atrocious. It’s Piazza – like. Even Paulie managed 23%, with that rag arm of his and a staff of pitchers who often didn’t even recognize runners on base. Torrealba’s agent assures us that the throw-out percentage was affected last year by a strained shoulder. Excuse me? This is supposed to make us feel better? Not only is the guy remarkably mediocre, but also damaged goods?

The truth is, Torrealba was once considered a great defensive catcher, because he had a fantastic arm. He had a gun, in that other realm of rifles occupied by Yadier Molina, Pudge, Tony Pena, Benito Santiago — you get the idea. His arm was his number-one strength and his ticket to the big leagues. Without it, he would be a career AAA player or washing cars right now.

However, his arm is not what it once was. Torrealba injured his shoulder while lifting weights during the 2005-2006 offseason. He claims he was lifting weights to try to become a better hitter. (Strange, since most hitters get better not by lifting weights but by working in the batting cage. But what the heck do I know?) As a result he landed on the DL TWICE in 2006. Hmm … shoulder “strain” in 2007, two shoulder injuries in 2006 … kind of sounds like a chronic issue, doesn’t it? Appears that shoulder is not getting better. Suffice to say, his throwing will continue to be affected.

Throughout his career, Yorvit Torrealba was described as a highly enthusiastic guy with a fantastic arm, but not much bat and therefore projected as a solid “catch and throw” second-stringer. His teammates gush about his energy and excitability. Those were/are his strengths: strong arm and energy. Except, he no longer has a strong arm, he has an injured arm. And he’ll never hit — especially not at Shea. So the Mets will be committing $15M to a guy with a lot of enthusiasm. Great.

Wouldn’t it be a lot cheaper and more productive to either a.) re-sign Paul LoDuca to a one-year deal or b.) wait for Miguel Olivo to be non-tendered? Hey, I’m not saying Olivo is a good choice, but he’s essentially the same player that Torrealba was (great arm, excitability), except with a bit more offense, and would be less expensive in terms of dollars and years.

Maybe the rumors are unfounded. Or perhaps, the Mets are signing Torrealba as a very expensive back up to the next backstop they acquire this winter.

Posted in 07-08 Offseason, Hot Stove | 16 Comments

An Appeal for Paulie

By the way, if you want to legally download the MP3 for this song (by Domenico Modugno), follow one of the links below and pay 89 cents:

Studio version: Nel Blu Dipinto Di Blu(Volare)

Live version: Volare (Live)

Posted in 07-08 Offseason | 1 Comment

Todd Jones Off the Market

A day before entering the “no holds barred” free-agent market, Todd Jones re-signed with the Tigers for one year, $7M. The Tigers became very desperate about their late-inning relief after Joel Zumaya hurt his shoulder moving boxes, an injury which will put him out of action until at least June 2008.

Doubtful that Jones would have been a target of the Mets, but it makes the relief market that much more sparse and relievers in even more demand.

Jacque Jones Dealt

In another Tiger transaction, the Cubs traded outfielder Jacque Jones to Detroit in return for Omar Infante. Strange move, in my ignorant opinion. Jones *might* have been the type of the outfielder the Mets would covet if they choose to trade Lastings Milledge for pitching — a righthanded veteran bat who would not require a long-term commitment.

Posted in 07-08 Offseason | Comments Off on Todd Jones Off the Market

Posada Wants to Be a Yankee

Ho-hum … Jorge Posada told reporters that he wants to be a Yankee:

“My first priority is the Yankees,” the five-time All-Star catcher told reporters Sunday at halftime of the New York Knicks’ game against the Miami Heat. “I would like to stay with the Yankees. My heart is with the Yankees, so hopefully we can get something done.”

OK, Jorge, that’s great. So then, what’s the holdup? If you want so badly to remain in pinstripes, why are you jerking them around? Why are you pretending to be interested in going crosstown to play in Queens? Oh, is it about the money? But according to your comments, it’s NOT about the money — unless, of course, your heart is for sale.

We’ve heard similar quotes from players before — all too recently in fact. For instance, Tom Glavine. Glavine’s “heart” was with Atlanta in the winter following the 2002 season. And after the 2006 season. And it appears to still be the case now. We’re tired of it from Tom, and bid him good riddance as he runs back to the Braves. Home is where the heart is. Flushing is where the money is.

If Jorge Posada is sincere about his heart being with the Yankees, we certainly hope that he paid close attention to the Tom Glavine Story. Glavine used the Mets as a negotiating ploy as well, back in 2002, thinking that the Braves would blink and give him the money he thought he deserved. But GM John Schuerholz didn’t blink, and Glavine was “stuck” with the millions of dollars promised by the Mets. That is, unless he wanted to crawl back to Atlanta with his tail between his legs, saying “I was only kidding!”

And this isn’t my view of what happened — it’s documented fact from Schuerholz’s book (OK, I took some liberty in the translation of the truth).

At this point, it appears as though Jorge Posada will be re-signing with his beloved Yankees. It’s probably for the best. Mets fans aren’t interested in players who would rather be playing for someone else.

Posted in 07-08 Offseason | 24 Comments

J.C. Romero Off the Market

Tricked by a half-season of hocus-pocus, the Philadelphia Phillies re-signed lefthanded reliever J.C. Romero to a 3-year, $12M contract.

You would think the Phils would have learned something from their NL East rivals the New York Mets and their similar over-valued assessment of Scott Schoeneweis a year ago.

Romero, an up-and-down middle reliever in the American League for about eight years, suddenly flourished in his NL debut last season, posting a 1.24 ERA in 51 appearances covering 36 innings for the Phillies. He was nearly unhittable, allowing just 15 hits in those 36 frames (though, he did walk 25 batters). Romero was particularly successful against the Mets, striking out 8 and allowing one run in 10 games.

It’s a near impossibility that the 31-year-old Romero will continue that kind of success over the next three years — both the statheads and the old-schoolers such as myself agree on that one. His instant success in the NL was strikingly similar to Schoeneweis, who after about 8 years (huh … how about that?) as an up-and-down starter, middle reliever, and LOOGY in the AL, turned into a superstar setup man and closer for the Cincinnati Reds at the tail end of 2006.

While Romero proved himself over 36 innings and The Show’s NL debut covered only 14, the comparison is eerie — especially when you consider that Schoeneweis continued his success for his first 10-15 innings with the Mets at the beginning of 2007.

Although Romero was lights-out for the Phillies last year, I’m not concerned about the signing. My bet is that Romero’s performance was a product of mystery in 2007, and that he’ll go back to his hum-drum AL numbers as soon as he’s further exposed. A reliever who walks nearly a batter an inning cannot possibly keep up that kind of success.

Posted in 07-08 Offseason | 1 Comment

Buzz on Livan, Yorvit

According to Buster Olney, the Mets will be targeting Livan Hernandez to fill the role of innings eater in the starting rotation.

And we have to PAY for this information from ESPN? Funny, thought the subject had been covered ad nauseam both here and on other subscription-free blogs. But hey, if you want to hear it from Buster, be my guest and crack out the credit card.

For the umpteenth time, I’ll state the painfully obvious: the Mets need a reliable, durable starter who can go deep into games — like into the 7th and occasionally the 8th. There are exactly two of those type of horses available on the FA market: Livan Hernandez and Carlos Silva. We fully expect Omar Minaya to speak with both of them and make a fair offer to either / both.

Marlins Like Torrealba

Strangely, the South Florida Sun-Sentinel reports that the Marlins are targeting Yorvit Torrealba to fill their “hole” behind the plate.

As Juan C. Rodriguez states,

“Improving the Marlins’ major league worst defense will start behind the plate. . . Don’t be surprised if the Marlins are the higher bidder. They told one rival general manager they’ve set aside a healthy allocation to address their catching deficiencies.”

To me it’s strange because Miguel Olivo has excellent raw skills for the catching position, particularly a rifle of an arm. Yes, he’s a bit screwed up in the head, but you have to be in order to catch (trust me, I’m a still a catcher in my late thirties and definitely screwed up in the head). Yes, Olivo made 19 errors and 26 passed balls in the past two years. But, a high number of catcher’s errors usually means you have a guy with a gun who is being ultra-aggressive. The passed balls are probably more the fault of the dozens of AA-level pitchers that Florida trots to the mound every year.

Though I suppose I can see the Marlins’ point; they’ve probably tired of Olivo’s shortcomings and don’t see him improving. What I don’t see is how Yorvit Torrealba is going to make a significant impact on the team’s success, and further, why you would make a guy like Torrealba your highest-paid player. It would seem to me they already have a Torrealba in Matt Treanor — give him the regular job and/or add a cheaper backstop to split time (i.e., Chad Moeller, Mike DiFelice, Einar Diaz, Corky Miller — there are plenty of “catch and throw guys” available).

When Torrealba’s agent was asked about his interest in joining the Marlins, he said,

“Yorvit would love it. They’re a good team, a young team, and Yorvit would be a great fit there. We’re going to be open to whatever situation. Florida is a good team that I know will be attractive for him.”

The article also noted that Torrealba had recently purchased a condo in South Florida, intending to split his time between there and his home in Venezuela.

Well it sounds to me like Yorvit could be going to the Marlins, if he doesn’t re-sign with the Rockies. And that is a GOOD thing — I’d hate to see the Mets get into a bidding war for Torrealba, who despite playing in a World Series is far from a championship-caliber catcher. Better to re-sign Paul LoDuca on a short-term deal with a home-team discount.

Posted in 07-08 Offseason | 4 Comments

Argument Against A-Rod

There is an extremely well-written piece at the Hardball Times by John Brattain titled “Battling Boras“, that I highly suggest you read. In a nutshell, it is Brattain’s response to several of the outrageous claims made by Scott Boras in touting his most expensive client — and by the end of the article you can see how Alex Rodriguez is NOT worth $300M. For example, would you pay Chipper Jones that kind of money? Yet, looking at the recent numbers, Chipper compares very closely to A-Rod. Go and read it for yourself.

Posted in 07-08 Offseason | 8 Comments