2009 Analysis: Jose Reyes

jose-reyes-benchObviously, Jose gets an “incomplete” for the 2009 season.

Reyes played in 36 games and was “day to day” for nearly a month before finally being placed on the 15-day disabled list — and was never seen again.

In the few games he played, Reyes hit .279 with a .750 OPS through 166 plate appearances It was a slow start for Jose, but no one was particularly concerned — he had similarly rough beginnings in 2005, 2006, and 2008. Eventually, Jose would “get it going”, and take the Mets with him.

So much for that thought. As it turned out, Jose Reyes was grounded for the season — as were the Mets.

Perhaps a better idea is to analyze the players who filled in for Reyes. Alex Cora played over his head initially — he played so well, in fact, that no one would have noticed Jose’s absence had he actually returned as quickly as initially indicated. Unfortunately, Cora eventually crashed to Earth, suffered two thumb injuries, and was barely adequate until he himself hit the DL. Ramon Martinez appeared like an apparition, and disappeared just as quickly and mysteriously. Wilson Valdez flashed a fancy glove and a rifle arm, but was underwhelming offensively. Anderson Hernandez was surprisingly improved at the plate and strong defensively about 75% of the time, but a space cadet for the other 25%. Angel Berroa appeared at the position 8 times — which was 8 times too many (“appeared” is the most complimentary thing we can say about his brief tenure). In short (pardon the pun), the Mets were left with a gaping hole between second and third once Reyes went down.

What 2010 brings for Jose Reyes is anyone’s guess. When fully healthy, he may be the most electrifying player in MLB, and potentially among the top 3 or 5 most productive all-around players in the game. The Mets have repeated on several occasions that Reyes will be “ready by spring training” after undergoing surgery on his hamstring. However we have learned not to trust those reports (see: Duaner Sanchez, John Maine, Luis Castillo, Carlos Beltran, Orlando Hernandez, etc.). Unless, of course, by “ready”, the Mets mean “capable of transporting himself to Port St. Lucie without aid of a wheelchair”. Hopefully, Reyes will return fully healed, fully rehabbed, and at full strength. But even then, will he return to the all-out, fearless terror on the basepaths that he was prior to the injury? Or will he be tentative, with the injury risk always looming in the back of his mind? Worse yet, will he again run around with reckless abandon, and re-injure that balky leg?

Contrary to popular opinion, Jose Reyes at 75-80% is NOT still better than most NL shortstops. The position is brimming with All-Stars around the league, including three from NL East Rivals. Reyes rises above only when he has his legs — 100% of his legs. Without them, he’s still very good, and keeps the Mets at a championship level for the position, but is not necessarily a difference-maker. And for the Mets to reach the postseason in 2010, they need him to be a difference-maker.

Perhaps also, the Mets need to consider acquiring a backup plan — just in case Reyes’ return doesn’t go as smoothly as everyone hopes.


Joe Janish began MetsToday in 2005 to provide the unique perspective of a high-level player and coach -- he earned NCAA D-1 All-American honors as a catcher and coached several players who went on to play pro ball. As a result his posts often include mechanical evaluations, scout-like analysis, and opinions that go beyond the numbers. Follow Joe's baseball tips on Twitter at @onbaseball and at the On Baseball Google Plus page.
  1. Tommy2cat November 3, 2009 at 11:16 am
    Great analysis. Pretty much sums it up.

    Perhaps Jerry Manuel might consider placing Reyes 2nd in the order if we acquire a bona fide lead-off hitter (eh-hem, such as Chone Figgins). The 2-slot would give Jose an opportunity to develop plate discipline, and he would likely benefit by the opposing pitcher distracted and pitching from the stretch. On one hand, Jose has both small-ball and gap power capability, which makes him suitable for the 2-slot. On the other hand, his OBP has never been his strength. This is just a though, not a campaign.

    We absolutely missed Jose’s glove…his range, his arm, his quick hands…everything. What more can we do than pray for his health to return? Develop or acquire a suitable back-up. Does Rueben Tejada fit the bill?

  2. Harry Chiti November 3, 2009 at 9:56 pm
    Why do people insist on making a player something he’s not. The more plate discipline Reyes shows the worse he hits. the more plate discipline the Braves shoved down Francouer the worse he got. Make him a dioscipined mediocrity and you will sorely miss the Jose of the last few years.