Mailbag: Dump David Wright

Off the heels of the recent news that Sandy Alderson will “move quickly” on extensions for R.A. Dickey and David Wright, I’ve received a flood of email from the teeming millions (OK, maybe not “millions;” more like, “dozens”). People are on both sides of the fence — a good mix of those supporting and against the plan for extending the two highest-performing Mets.

Here is an email from one side of the fence:

I just read about the Mets planning to extend David Wright…if the Mets do, it will be their biggest mistake.

Wright completely disappeared in the 2nd half and his hitting had been pathetic … I do not want him back with the Mets and it is time for the Mets to deal him to another team (throw in Mike Pelfrey and closer Frank Francisco for proven veterans who will be able to help the Mets … Wright has been a damn joke and I am sick and tired of him.

We need a power hitter who also hits for average and don’t tell me Wright is that kind of hitter…he is most assuredly not so…

We also need quality pitchers as a starter and a closer … Pelfrey had been out all year and I don’t want him back and neither do I want Francisco back … he’s been horrific as a closer …

The Mets had gone through another tiresome collapse and I just want to puke … it’s time to end all this nonsense and start building the team from inside out … if it means a couple more years before they can reach postseason status, I am all for it … Wright is garbage and he belongs in the dumpster!

– Jay H., Bernardsville, NJ

Jay, thank you for your email. Though you did not ask for my response, I’ll post it here anyway.

First off, Continue reading

Posted in 12-13 Offseason | Tagged | 20 Comments

Don’t Give Up…Yet (Part One)

Deceptively, baseball looks like an easy game to play. Most of the players seem to be of average height and weight; the rules and strategies are fairly straightforward and as George Carlin has pointed out, it’s a game played in a park where the objective is to be safe at home. Partially as a result, it can be easy to get down quickly on players who don’t meet expectations. In a market like New York “quickly” is an understatement as calls for a player’s head can be heard after a single 0-fer game. After a whole season of this, the fanbase’s desire to banish said player to the remotest outpost in baseball can border on the irrational.

Recently, I was reminded of just how hard this game is. I coach my son’s Fall League baseball team and a sudden downpour ruined the field for game conditions. With a collection of players in uniform and ready to go, we decided on an impromptu intrasquad scrimmage. To round out the teams, a few parents participated. My sole at bat was against my 11 year old son. He’s a big (5’ 5”) kid to begin with and he can put some heat on his pitches. He obviously relished the chance to face dear old dad on a level playing field. He buzzed me inside twice, much to the bemusement of the onlookers. He came in again on a third pitch which jammed me, but I was able to get around on it and hit a roller out past an admittedly disinterested second baseman into right field. Later, I took a seat in the dugout next to my wife, whom our son had fanned on three pitches. “Not as easy as it looks,” she remarked.

Now what does this tender family moment have to do with the Mets? A reminder of just how true those five words are. Under the best of conditions, the game is extremely difficult to play and even the top players fail two out of three times. There is an adjustment level from the Triple- or Double-A to the Major League level and for some young men, coming from a small close-knit community to the world’s loudest metropolis can be overwhelming. To top it off, some of these players are also forced to change positions or be the replacement for a popular incumbent. For every David Wright, Edgardo Alfonzo or (hopefully) Matt Harvey who arrived here and had immediate and lasting success, there are other players who needed the time and mentoring to adjust to the talent, sights, sound and sometimes even the language of their big league surroundings. Fernando Vina, Jeromy Burnitz, Jason Isringhausen, Jeff Kent and **sigh** Nolan Ryan are a few examples of players the Mets gave up on too soon, traded away for next to nothing and watched as they blossomed into good and in two cases, great players elsewhere. While I don’t think the Mets have a future Nolan Ryan in their organization, they may well indeed have another Vina, a Burnitz, an Izzy and maybe even a Kent in the fold already.

Who are they? You’ll have check back here tomorrow to find out!

Posted in 12-13 Offseason | 1 Comment

SI: Mets to extend Dickey, Wright “Quickly”

He already has a book deal…

According to a story from Sports Illustrated’s Fannation.com, Sandy Alderson intends to extend R.A. Dickey and David Wright soon, perhaps even before the World Series:

Sandy Alderson’s definition of “quickly,” when it comes to David Wright‘s and R.A Dickey’s future with the Mets, could mean before the first pitch of the World Series is even thrown. The Mets general manager made it clear earlier this week a resolution on both players’ futures could come quickly. A baseball source with knowledge of the team’s thinking was more specific yesterday, saying it’s conceivable Wright and Dickey will have new deals in place, at least in principle, by the time the World Series begins later this month. Wright and Dickey are under club control for 2013, but have indicated they will test free agency next offseason if they do not receive new contracts by spring training.

Strictly from an emotional fan perspective, I felt relieved to read this.  Signing Dickey and Wright would be great for the morale of the fans and the players.

Thinking about it rationally, I’m not sure this is the right move.  Perhaps one or both could be traded for major league ready outfielders or a catcher or some other need.  They might be able to fill, say, 4 other positions in exchange for these two players.

But how plausible would it be to replace their production?  Dickey may never have another 20-win season with a 2.73 ERA, but he will likely give the Mets 7 good innings every five days  32 or 33 times a year.  He’s shown that ability not just in 2012, but in his previous 2 seasons with the Mets.  And for as much as David Wright regressed to the mean in the second half, a team with little extra base power needs a player who can hit 40+ doubles and 20+ home runs.  Wright has done that consistently in years he’s been healthy, except for 2009.

Once again, the Mets don’t have a lot of money to spend this offseason, and many needs to fill.  Sandy Alderson will have to get creative on the trade market.  If he extends Dickey and Wright, two of his most valuable trade chips are off the table.  However, the Mets will be assured that they will have an ace pitcher and an All-Star third baseman heading into 2013.

 

Posted in News Notes Rumors | Tagged , , , , | 10 Comments

Former Mets in the Postseason

The Mets can’t make it to the postseason, but at least some former Mets are able to get in. Continue reading

Posted in Off Topic | 6 Comments

Quick Thoughts On Wild Card Night

It’s such a pleasure to watch real MLB teams play incredibly important games. The Mets haven’t competed like this in six years.

The Braves were HOSED. That infield fly call — on a ball that was about a hundred feet from the infield — was embarrassing for MLB. Still, the Braves choked when they had opportunities to rise above, and made some terrible physical errors to beat themselves; they didn’t look anything like a Bobby Cox club.

I found myself rooting for the Braves to beat the Cardinals, because, apparently, I hate the Cardinals more than I hate the Braves.

Is it me or is half of Baltimore’s roster former Mets?

By the way, how can you not root for the Orioles? Look at that roster, that lineup, and the turnover of that pitching staff, and explain to me how the heck they’ve gone this far.

Toward that explanation: is Buck Showalter the 2012 version of Bobby Valentine circa 2000?

Speaking of Valentine, he’s available again. Just sayin’.

I wasn’t sad at all to see the Rangers eliminated. They managed to accomplish the most drastic and rapid collapse since the 2008 or 2007 Mets (pick one).

Joe Nathan was looking a lot like Brad Lidge.

Josh Hamilton was a non-entity. Maybe he should have drowned down an energy drink or cup of coffee before the game.

Why can’t Bobby Parnell evolve into Jim Johnson?

The Cardinals, Braves, and Orioles all have backup catchers who could start for the Mets. The Rangers have both a backup and a third-string catcher who could start for the Mets.

Nate McLouth hit rock bottom, and somehow found his way into being the leadoff hitter for a playoff team. Have to wonder how he fell so far, so fast — could it have had something to do with supplements?

Manny Machado‘s RBI single in the ninth on a tough two-strike slider reminded me of a young Derek Jeter.

Your thoughts after the first day of the MLB postseason?

Posted in Mets 2012 Games | 5 Comments

Mets Game 162: Win Over Marlins

Mets 4 Marlins 2

Wait till next year! Continue reading

Posted in Mets 2012 Games | Tagged , | 32 Comments

Mets Game 161: Loss to Marlins

Marlins 4 Mets 3

One more to go … Continue reading

Posted in Mets 2012 Games | Tagged , , | 13 Comments

Blog Roundup: October Baseball

See guys, the Mets ARE playing in October, amirite?

Just two more games to go, and lucky for us, R.A. Dickey is pitching in one of them.  Tonight, Dickey goes for win number 21.  Furthermore, a good performance would cement his case for the Cy Young award.

Let’s see what the Blogs are talking about:

Thanks for reading Mets Today all season long, and keep checking us out for coverage of what will surely be  an interesting offseason.

Posted in Around the Blogs | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on Blog Roundup: October Baseball